In last five years or so, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have grown in numbers and it asset values. In my view, ETF is another form of investing vehicle available (among many others) to investing or trading community. The major attraction for ETF has been low cost expenses and fees in comparison to mutual funds and ability in trade during market hours. Like any other investing vehicles, I believe ETFs are good vehicles depending upon how/why an individual investor uses in its portfolio. The simplicity with which you can buy and sell an ETF makes it even more difficult to understand how it is structured, what are its constituents, etc., So before you buy an ETF you much understand why you want to buy it and what role it plays in your portfolio. Broad market exposure and access to alternative assets are two important roles ETF can play in your portfolios.
Last week, I presented an update on the monthly progress of my dividend portfolio. In this post, I am discussing the quarterly risk analysis. My objective here to make sure I am continuing to following my risk management process.
- Maintain pre-determined asset class allocation;
- Maintain pre-determined diversification (any sector should not exceed 10%); and
- Dividends from a single stock should not exceed 5% of total dividends.
My dividend portfolio holdings can be referenced in My Portfolio menu at top of this page.
Maintaining Asset Allocation
Chart 1 shows the asset class allocation along with my maximum target limits. In general, I am continuing to meet (or much closer) to my pre-defined target levels. During 3Q09, I did not make any contribution to the emerging markets index funds such as VWO and EPI. This was because I believe they rose too quickly to my comfort level. I am still tad lower than my maximum limit for emerging markets.
As the stock markets continue to recover (assuming it has not done yet), the talk of inflation is coming back in the news. Our government has pumped in so much of printed money in the system that there is a concern that US economy will experience inflationary times. There is no denying that inflation will take away chunk of our real returns from overall investing returns.
Many of the well known economists and investors (including Warren Buffett) have expressed concerns about inflation. Among all the experts and pundits, I believe, David Swensen gave a very pragmatic and down to earth response to this question in an interview on WealthTrack. According to Swensen, he does not know what will happen. He cannot predict it. There will be inflation if the recent pumping of money supports the economy and growth returns to US economy. If there is no growth, then there will be deflation of dollar value. His message was to address these issues with proper diversification and asset allocation. As individual investors what can we do to (or rather how can we) blunt the effect of inflation or deflation. Following are five aspects one can look into to manage their asset diversification.
As individual investors we all know that we need to maintain a diversified asset allocation in our portfolios. We are also aware of different types of asset class and invest
Theoretically, asset allocation is a risk manage
In this context, I looked at David Swensen’s work with Yale Endow
In this table, we can see that every asset class has its own expected return and its corresponding standard deviation. In general, I was quite surprised by the single digit expected real return and higher percentage of standard deviations (in 20s). The expected real return excludes inflation, but still it appears to be quite different than the generally purported value of approximately 10% (do
The interesting point in this asset allocation
- Looking at my asset allocation from the viewpoint of risk-to-dividend (referenced in Dividend Tree Holdings)
- Use of ‘expected dividend return/growth’ instead of expected return (will discuss in future posts).
In the earlier post, I discussed that risk manage
- Maintain diversified asset allocation;
- Continuity of the stock to
meet my buying objective;
- Companies’ ability to consistently grow dividends; and
- Dividends from a single stock should not exceed 5% of total dividends.
Today in this post I am using above criteria’s to analyze (and action taken) my dividend portfolio. My dividend portfolio holdings can be referenced in “My Holding”
Maintaining diversified asset allocation
I look at asset allocation in three different ways viz. (i) asset class; (ii) industry sectors; and (iii) morningstar style classification. For each type of analysis, I have a pre-defined target levels. At this point in ti
- For asset class, in general, I am continuing to
meet (or much closer) to my pre-defined targets levels. E merging market is one asset class for which I do not have any exposure. This is one area in which I need to do more work.
- For industry sectors, I have a pre-defined maximum limit of 10% for each sector. The chart shows that I higher exposure (relative to my limit) in financial derivates (i.e CEFs), healthcare, and real estate. The health care exposure is limited to JNJ and PFE. At this point in ti
me, both are good quality stocks. So I intend to continue holding it with no further capital allocation. Financial derivates is a sector, where I will reduce my exposure.
- The chart for morningstar style classification shows that my dividend portfolio is concentrated around large cap value and growth stocks. Intuitively that seems to be correct because majority of the dividend-growth stocks are stable and mature companies. I may perhaps need to add mid cap stocks. I will be looking into this.
Continuity of the stock to
Qualitatively, except AOD and IGD, all of the positions that I have in my dividend portfolio continue to
- Based on this criterion; AOD (shifting concentration from international to US-Based), and IGD (return of capital) are two stocks which are in probation.
Companies’ ability to consistently grow dividends
All the stocks continue to
- PID is an index ETF which continues to
meet my buying objective. Therefore, I intend to continue to holding PID even though it is not growing the dividends.
- Based on this criterion alone; GE (no increase), IIA (managed distribution, no increase), IGD (return of capital based distribution) are three stocks which are in probation.
Individual stock dividend less than 5% of total dividends
The chart shows that GE (~10%) and AOD (~20%) exceeds my pre-defined limit by significant amount. I will need to scale back my exposure to ensure that dividend cuts do not affect my passive cash flow.
My asset allocation showed that I had excessive exposure to financial derivates (IGD, IIA, AOD) and I had higher exposure to risk-to-dividend (
- I reduced my holding in GE by selling partial positions. My dividends from GE are now only 5.5%.
- I have put IGD in the sell block. IGD is an example from my high yield chasing days when I was still learning different aspects of distributions such as inco
me, qualified dividends, ROC, short gain, long gains etc. I do not believe it is a good quality invest ment because majority of the distribution consist of return of capital. Selling IGD will also help in reducing my exposure to fund based invest ments. I am evaluating when to sell.
- I am continuing with IIA a real estate based inco
meCEF. It continues to meet my buying objective and maintains stable dividend annually.
- My concern with AOD is the CEF has transfor
med from 65%+ international allocation to 65%+ US-based allocation. I am no longer getting international exposure with AOD (which was my buying objective). However, my current capital allocation for AOD is 6.2% which I expect to reduce further with more stock purchases in this quarter. Additionally, my existing YOC is in excess of 20%. Assuming dividend reduction by 10 to 15%, even then my YOC will be well above 5% and it will reduce my single stock dividend to approx 10% or even less. With this background, I intend to continue holding AOD. I will be looking into changing my objective to hold this stock.
I hope with this approach to risk-based allocation, I will reduce my risk to dividend cash flow and continue to maintain potential for capital appreciation.